Get Free Ebook Who Will Lead Us?: The Story of Five Hasidic Dynasties in America
Get Free Ebook Who Will Lead Us?: The Story of Five Hasidic Dynasties in America
Being a better person occasionally most likely is tough to do. Additionally, altering the old routine with the brand-new practice is hard. Really, you may not need to transform instantly the old routine to talking. Hanging around, or juts gossiping. You will require detailed activity. In addition, the means you will certainly alter your routine is by the analysis practice. It will certainly make so tough obstacle to resolve.
Who Will Lead Us?: The Story of Five Hasidic Dynasties in America
Get Free Ebook Who Will Lead Us?: The Story of Five Hasidic Dynasties in America
There are many publications that can be prospects to check out in this recent era. Nonetheless, it could be impossible for you to read as well as complete them at once. To conquer this problem, you need to select the very first book and make prepare for various other books to review after finishing. If you're so overwhelmed, we suggest you to select Who Will Lead Us?: The Story Of Five Hasidic Dynasties In America as your analysis resource.
As known, book Who Will Lead Us?: The Story Of Five Hasidic Dynasties In America is popular as the home window to open the globe, the life, as well as brand-new point. This is exactly what individuals now need a lot. Also there are many people that do not like reading; it can be a selection as referral. When you truly need the means to develop the next motivations, book Who Will Lead Us?: The Story Of Five Hasidic Dynasties In America will really lead you to the means. Moreover this Who Will Lead Us?: The Story Of Five Hasidic Dynasties In America, you will have no remorse to obtain it.
Well, in order to supply the best publication suggested, we lead you to get the link. This website constantly displays the web link that is adapted the book that is extended. And this moment, Who Will Lead Us?: The Story Of Five Hasidic Dynasties In America in soft data system is coming. This coming book is also given in soft documents. So, you can set it securely in the devices. If you generally discover the printed book to read, currently you can locate guide in soft data.
So, that's so clear that obtaining Who Will Lead Us?: The Story Of Five Hasidic Dynasties In America an among reading materials will certainly supply some benefits. To get this book, just allow join us to be member and obtain the links of every book to serve. Then, simply check out as well as obtain guide. It will not need much time to invest. It will also not lose your time. Your precious time should be called for by possessing this publication as yours.
Review
"One might expect to find these riveting succession stories—of the rebbes of the Munkacs, Boyan and Kopyczynitz, Bobover, Satmar, and Chabad Lubavitch dynasties—in a TV mini-series rather than in a work of sociology and history. While fueled by an enormous amount of research, they read more like page turners where the obsession is not sex, but succession." (Moment 2017-05-15) "An invaluable addition to the ranks of objective studies of a Jewish movement that continues to flourish in the U.S. even as more modern denominations decline." (Publishers Weekly 2017-06-26) “Heilman has drawn on many sources which he presents to us for the first time. He writes like a novelist thus making this a book that is hard to put down.†(Reviews by Amos Lassen) “Riveting. . . . A great read!†(Haemtza) "Anyone interested in Jewish history mixed with a bit of palace intrigue will enjoy this book.†(Jewish Book Council) "Engrossing . . . . Required reading for anyone interested in the contemporary hasidic world." (Seforim) "An in-depth analysis of how a very particular part of the Jewish world confronts modernity, post-Holocaust society, the modern nation-state of Israel, and a flourishing American Jewish community." (CHOICE 2018-01-01) "Who Will Lead Us? includes many great stories, all of them sharply and engagingly told. Heilman’s account of the fight over the leadership of the Bobovers (resolved after years of infighting by the New York State Supreme Court) is worth the price of the hard cover volume alone." (Jewish Review of Books) "Once again, students of Judaism and religious traditionalism are indebted to Heilman for his brilliant and insightful work." (Contemporary Jewry) "Anyone interested in Jewish history mixed with a bit of palace intrigue will enjoy this book." (Jewish Book Review)
Read more
From the Inside Flap
“Who Will Lead Us? brilliantly demonstrates that the remarkable resurrection of Hasidism has been due to its capacity for maintaining the charismatic authority of its dynastic leadership. This is by far the most insightful study of the social, economic, and political dynamics of Hasidim today.”—Ada Rapoport-Albert, Professor Emerita of Jewish Studies at University College London “What happens to dynasties when they meet America? This is a fascinating tale of the struggles over succession that plague today’s Hasidic communities. Told with a richness of detail and insider knowledge that only Samuel Heilman could muster.”—Art Green, Professor Emeritus of Near Eastern and Judaic Studies at Brandeis University “Once again, Samuel Heilman has opened the opaque world of contemporary Hasidism to his readers. With a rare blend of historical depth and sociological breadth, he offers up five case studies that explore the fraught process of leadership transition in Hasidic courts. This is a gripping story about Hasidic Jews, but it is also about religious leadership more generally in the modern age.”—David Myers, Sady and Ludwig Kahn Professor of Jewish History at UCLA
Read more
See all Editorial Reviews
Product details
Hardcover: 336 pages
Publisher: University of California Press; First edition (June 6, 2017)
Language: English
ISBN-10: 0520277236
ISBN-13: 978-0520277236
Product Dimensions:
6 x 1 x 9 inches
Shipping Weight: 1.2 pounds (View shipping rates and policies)
Average Customer Review:
4.2 out of 5 stars
23 customer reviews
Amazon Best Sellers Rank:
#511,444 in Books (See Top 100 in Books)
While this book is definitely well researched, I don't see it as very comprehensive. A rather thin book, the author only reviews five stories of Chassidic Rebbes.For some reason, he chose to write only on chassidus in North America, automatically limiting the material there is to study. This could have been a very good book, had he studied numerous other courts outside of the US, such as Belz, Vizhnits, and Stolin. His work is therefore not a comprehensive study of chassidic revival, rather a study of 5 rebbes in North America. The story of Boyan is actually mainly a story of the rebirth of Boyaner Chassidus in Israel, which makes one wonder why he included that and not other Israeli Chassidim.His discussion on Chabad is mainly about what happened before WW1, after the petirah of the Tzemach Tzedek, and after the petirah of the Maharash. All other information of the current rebbe, there is very little that is not already known, and was just put there to fill up space.He tries to say that since there is no official photo of the maharash in chabad, that implies that he was somehow less influential than the other rebbes. That seems ridiculous, there is no photo because no photographer managed to photograph him.He tries to paint the Boyaner rebbe as coming from a modern orthodox family, who married into an ultra orthodox insular chareidi family, while in reality his own family and the family he married into weren't very different.He claims that Satmar chassidim don't respect their current rebbes as much as the previous ones, based on the fact that there is no biography of them. However, the common custom among most chareidim is not to write biographies about their rabbis when they are still alive. It is surprising that someone who spent most of his career studying chareidim, is apparently unaware of this.
The book is a sociology study on Hasidim, a society dispersed all over the world, comprising of strictly ultra Orthodox Jews, who follow a few leaders who are descended from royal families. Hasidim, loosely translated as ‘followers’, Initially meant ‘the pious ones’ denoting, doing above and beyond of what is required of them.Authored by the celebrated sociologist, Samuel Heilman, told through the stories of a selected five Hasidic American sects, interviewing its leaders, analyzing its history and its current status. The first two dynasties cannot find any leaders, the next two dynasties have too many leaders fighting each other, the last dynasty is left completely leaderless, living through Messianism.Samuel Heilman is a world renowned professor of Sociology in Queens College CUNY. And the chair of Jewish studies at The Graduate Center of CUNY. Himself a descendant of Hasidim, he does great justice to this subject. Seems like he infused the two of his life long fields, sociology and Judaic studies, to construct a comprehensive monumental guide book on Hasidim.Heilman has been forever the utmost authoritative voice on Hasidim, not only because of his diligent academic work, but also due to his own faith of Judaism, that inspires him to give narrative, motive, and context, to Jewish life. Being a teacher he is a constructive critic, often very frank and open.Heilman is a prolific writer and a provocative thinker, his columns are regularly published in many major journals and newspapers. He has authored more than ten books. His latest one, before this one, generated much attention, also from the Hasidim defending their leader, their Rebbe, trying to guard his elevated status as pious, from Heilman’s claims, supported with documents and family interviews, from his youth, - otherwise.This new book is a direct out birth of his last one, and runs on the same theme, applied to the whole collective of Hasidim. With input from different dynasties and sects. And accesses other leaders’ lives and histories as well.It is also a remarkable renaissance story. As it argues that Hasidim should have been extinct after the Holocaust. Yet it is alive bigger than ever. Despite its own leaders, giving up on an American Judaism, never mind an American Hasidism. How did it happen? This book spells out the right answer. And in the process, captivates the reader with this miraculous account. Turns out the Holocaust was not at all a detriment. To the contrary, it fueled the evolution of Hasidim today.As a professional sociologist and anthropologist the author breaks into this hermetically closed knit isolated Hasidic people, to produce a structural crystal clear scientific case, of how Hasidim’s mass and energy, is constantly gaining ferocity and strength, in the orbits around their leaders, the Rebbes. He captures not only the personal struggles of those endeared leaders’ - the Rebbes. But proves, how their intensity, their punch is felt by the collective. The leaders’ most private setbacks or conquerings, reverberates into the public sphere of their flock, the followers, the Hasidim, affecting and shaping them.Hasidim are a society apart, yet are deeply entrenched in the broader society surrounding it, through geography, economics, politics. Still they are estranged and hidden from their closest neighbors. This book will teach you the fundamental sociological underlying stirrings like, Collective Effervescence, Charisma and Conflict. That made and sustains Hasidim, in such a uniquely powerful society unparalleled in history.Hasidim are directly affecting and influencing the world, since they live at the heart and vortex of the most modern place on earth, New York City, and in other strategically important places. They change the way of living. Primarily through their block-vote power, as Hasidim vote in huge united blocks, which is most powerful, to choke the individualistic interest from the general electorates, they wield tremendous sway to win out on social policy, that often defy reason, science, health, and even education, when it clashes with their own rituals, beliefs and traditions.Hasidim, primarily the men, are ubiquitous in the broader society. With their unique attire, mostly bespectacled; bearded; “Payos†- hairlocs adorning the two sides of their forehead; and traditional garb; black hats; black coats, - even in the scorching heat; white shirts, etc. - They seem to be everywhere. Even the women, who are less a presence in the workforce, except as secretaries, but more allowed to flout colors on their bodies, being a patriarchal society. You see them shopping with baby carriages in all the malls. - Hasidim stand out wherever you go.This sociology book reckons with its vibrancy and dominance. It is a highly objectively balanced work of research, evenly sourced, and referenced very extensively. It's based on so many other books before it about Hasidim. No doubt It will be the accepted lasting fundamental textbook, for many generations to come, to study Hasidim.The book is sculptured, by the many leaders themselves, the Rebbes’ input. And their followers, the Hasidims’ collaboration, albeit a few of them anonymously as the book explains why in the prologue of the book. But they all have been interrogated by Heilman first hand, Many on the record, very few off the record, all trusting him to balance the big picture while documenting it. Two of those interviewed very well respected leaders have just recently already died after he has written the book, and some are sick and old, and many will be with us for a long time, - all find their unique voices interwoven to form this great Hasidic sociology anthology, written down to history by the master of sociology, Samuel Heilman, who makes all the right calls, and hard decisions, which arguments and narratives gets credence, and which are voided.There are other dynasties by Hasidim. The author chose to delve into these five mainly, because he felt, as he makes the case very succinctly, that they best explain Hasidim on a whole, thru each of their very unique vibrant transforming powers that exemplify Hasidim at large currently:1. The dynasty of Minkatch was an especially conservative sect, that crowned a third son for its leader, instead of his father, because the later embraced too much modernity.2. The dynasty of Boyan left behind the American way of life that the whole leader's family chose to live, and instead plucked out a young teen, to shoo him off to Israel dogmatizing him with right wing Judaism to be their leader.3. The dynasty of Bobov, initially rebuilt in America on charisma, song, holocaust nostalgia. Only to subsequently split off into royal family feuding.4. The Satmar dynasty best exemplifies Hasidim. They are the most fervently fanatically attached to their traditional faith, yet materialy very successful. They are the largest and most diverse group, having multiple leaders, splintered with sectarian strife, fighting to better preserve their purest version of Jewishness, not giving an inch to modernity.5. Then there is the last dynasty, Chabad-Lubavitch, which are the polar opposite of all Hasidim, completely leaderless and engaging modernity, in order to missionize the world with their Messianic fervor to stay relevant as Hasidm without any leader whatsoever.So much, of the same narratives, repeats itself over and over in all of these five dynasties in real life. But the author chooses to recount only those which best illustrates the Hasidic full picture, more uniquely from each chapter. So to get the whole picture, the reader will have to absorb all five chapters on all the dynasties.And in order to fully grasp all its lofty concepts, and extensively discussed characters, the reader first must digest the prologue chapter, and afterwards, the final thoughts’ chapter, where it all comes together in one compact short closing argument concluding summary.The notes chapter guides you further to explore the issues at hand. It's engrossing looking up the sources, for the many claims, while reading the book itself, because it's based on the widest array of the spectrum. From hagiography to autobiography works. From academic critical history volumes, to religious biblical, talmudic, halachic and hashkafa, - Jewish thought writings, throughout the generations.To be honest in my assessment, with full disclosure that I am a Hasid, I must admit that in the beginning i feared him, because as he himself writes in the prologue of the book, apologising for demeaning us, he expresses regrets, that many people will no doubt be embarrassed by his work. After finishing the book, more than once, I ultimately not only forgive him, but really thank him for writing it, because i am convinced my world will be a better one through this work.I can attest that Hasidim like me are mesmerised by Its dripping godly holiness, due to its putting Hasidic society under the microscopic transparency lens. It resurrects the Hasidic pulse, its heart beat. Its ailments and survival. its aliveness, and its blind spots, - onto the written word, that is so riveting in substance and in style.It is true that Hasidim despise all academic meditations, even Jewish studies, if it's written by a general scholar, because of its dangerous modernity effects the author engraves on the reader. But this sociology study is processed by us Hasidim, because we don't want to assimilate. We want to preserve our holy tradition. This book only helps perfect this ideal quest.And as for the universal readership, due to Hasidim being a block-vote power in the western democracies all over the world, they are becoming fast, as we speak, the biggest most powerful force today, and in the immediate future. Hasidim have simply grown too large to be ignored. Too real to be denied as just another group of humans. This sociology book tells the world and history, why Hasidim exist, persevere and rule.No wonder this book is such a bestseller! As you can see in this link:https://www.amazon.com/gp/new-releases/books/12807/ref=zg_b_hnr_12807_1
These are fascinating tales beautifully told of the rise to Hasidic leadership and a most fascinating tale of a rabbinic failure. We often think of Hasidim as blind followers. This book shows how false is that perception.
Not really an academic paper, but not too far removed from it in the way it uses facts derived from original documents. I really enjoyed reading this history of 5 different Hasidic dynasties. Some basic familiarity with Hasidic Judaism is helpful when reading this.
Heilman is just a magnificent storyteller. I learned so much.
Fascinating. I couldn't put it down
Innuendos about the sexual issues of a great tzadik make for titillating reading but detract from the quality if an otherwise enjoyable read.
Great historical description of a unique situation
Who Will Lead Us?: The Story of Five Hasidic Dynasties in America PDF
Who Will Lead Us?: The Story of Five Hasidic Dynasties in America EPub
Who Will Lead Us?: The Story of Five Hasidic Dynasties in America Doc
Who Will Lead Us?: The Story of Five Hasidic Dynasties in America iBooks
Who Will Lead Us?: The Story of Five Hasidic Dynasties in America rtf
Who Will Lead Us?: The Story of Five Hasidic Dynasties in America Mobipocket
Who Will Lead Us?: The Story of Five Hasidic Dynasties in America Kindle
Who Will Lead Us?: The Story of Five Hasidic Dynasties in America PDF
Who Will Lead Us?: The Story of Five Hasidic Dynasties in America PDF
Who Will Lead Us?: The Story of Five Hasidic Dynasties in America PDF
Who Will Lead Us?: The Story of Five Hasidic Dynasties in America PDF
Related posts
Share this post
0 komentar: