Ebook Free Nicaea and Its Legacy: An Approach to Fourth-Century Trinitarian Theology
Ebook Free Nicaea and Its Legacy: An Approach to Fourth-Century Trinitarian Theology
Don't undervalue; the books that we gather them are not just from inside of this nation. You can additionally learn the books from outside of the country. They are all additionally various with various other. Some links are offered to reveal you where to discover and also get it. This Nicaea And Its Legacy: An Approach To Fourth-Century Trinitarian Theology as one of the instances can be gained easily. And why you need to suggest this publication for yourselves and also your friends is that this book holds crucial function to improve your life high quality and also quantity.
Nicaea and Its Legacy: An Approach to Fourth-Century Trinitarian Theology
Ebook Free Nicaea and Its Legacy: An Approach to Fourth-Century Trinitarian Theology
Currently existing! A book that will certainly offer great influences for you! A book has lots with the day-to-day condition around. This publication is a publication that has actually been developed by a seasoned author. For the outcome, the author actually has wonderful lead to draw in the readers. It causes the title of this book is also so intriguing. Nicaea And Its Legacy: An Approach To Fourth-Century Trinitarian Theology is this publication title.
Reading is type of should do every day. Like what you do your day-to-day tasks, consuming or doing your day-to-day tasks. And currently, why should be reading? Reading, once more, could aid you to discover brand-new manner in which will certainly get you to life better. That's not exactly what you call as the responsibility. You could review Nicaea And Its Legacy: An Approach To Fourth-Century Trinitarian Theology in the leisure as added activities. It will not also obligate you to review it for many pages. Simply, by steps and also you could see just how this publication remarkably.
This idea is due to the fact that we offer the soft data of guide. When other people bring the hard publication everywhere, you can just hold your gadget. Conserving the soft data of Nicaea And Its Legacy: An Approach To Fourth-Century Trinitarian Theology in your gizmo will certainly relieve you in reading. When you are being at residence, you can also open in the computer. So, conserving guide soft data in some gadgets are offered. It will certainly simplify of you to discover how the activity is mosting likely to be extremely basic due to the advanced technology.
After getting guide, you can start your activity to read it, even in your spare time every where you are. You can recognize why we prepared make it as advised publication for you. This is not just regarding the appropriate topic for your analysis source but additionally the more suitable book with high quality components. So, it will not make puzzled to feel stressed not to obtain anything from Nicaea And Its Legacy: An Approach To Fourth-Century Trinitarian Theology
Review
"Bold and erudite...This ambitious work justly shows how crucial the study of the fourth century is for understanding traditional or mainstream trinitarian theology, and it has succeeded already in fostering greater conversation toward this end." --Journal of Religion
Read more
About the Author
Lewis Ayres is Assistant Professor of Historical Theology at the Candler School of Theology and the Graduate Division of Religion, Emory University.
Read more
Product details
Paperback: 496 pages
Publisher: Oxford University Press (June 22, 2006)
Language: English
ISBN-10: 0198755058
ISBN-13: 978-0198755050
Product Dimensions:
9 x 1.1 x 6.1 inches
Shipping Weight: 2 pounds (View shipping rates and policies)
Average Customer Review:
3.5 out of 5 stars
9 customer reviews
Amazon Best Sellers Rank:
#201,020 in Books (See Top 100 in Books)
I just finished reading Lewis Ayres weighty book on Nicaea. While I thoroughly enjoyed the book and learned a great deal, it is a hard book to read. The arguments are dense and involved, citing Greek and Latin terms as well as technical academic vocabulary. I had to look up a number of terms over and over again to follow Ayres's thinking. I say this as an academic myself, albeit a biblical scholar, specifically an Old Testament scholar with over 30 years teaching experience, two masters degrees and a PhD. The book is very good, but beware it is a hard read.Here is my take-aways after many hours of working through the text.1. One cannot easily divide into Eastern and Western views of the Trinity during this period. There is too much shared material and ideas. The older paradigm of East vs West does not hold.2. The development of Nicaean or Pro-Nicene doctrines was a long political struggle. I don't know how many persons were exiled and then returned, then exiled, then returned before the controversy ended, if ever it did.3. It seems the best summaries of Pro-Nicene doctrine can be found in the two Gregorys and in Augustine. If one wants to start there and then work backwards, one would find the best pathway.4. Ayres is very critical of current Trinitarian writing and research, particularly German authors and their legacy, stemming from Hegel. I found this fascinating. The two thrusts of Hegel he sights are: A. Conflating life of the Trinity with world process or the development of the Spirit/Geist (Hegel). After reading his argument, I found a lot of truth to what he says. But I also see involvement of YHWH in the OT and Jesus's actions in the NT as God interacting with the world. So, some caution here, but I think Ayres is on target, Too many modern Trinitarian works easily map the life of the Trinity onto world process. B. Linking the relationships of the Trinity to psychological categories. I find this line of thinking to be very on-target. Read for example Richard Rohr in the area of spiritual practice and see how he virtually maps the Trinity onto human psychology.5. Ayres draws attention to the pathway that Pro-Nicenes pursue in reading Scripture, from reading the plain sense of Scripture, to thinking and pondering, to finally union with the mystery of the Trinity itself. I like this, as I am both a biblical scholar and as well a trained Spiritual Director. I find absent from my academic teaching setting any emphasis that the people both reading and writing Trinitarian doctrine during the 4th century were actually attempting to get in touch with God, not just analyze a text. This is refreshing. People didn't study the Trinity to write academic paper. They did so to meet God.I gave this book 4 stars not because of its content and argument, but because it is just darn hard to read, even for an academic like me.
If you are interested in the development of doctrine as it occured at Nicea in the fourth century, this is an excellent book showing not only the development of doctrine but that modern scholars can fully comprehend the issues and nuances of the issue. I truly enjoyed it and learned much.
A
A fantastic book. A must read for anyone interested in topic. The reason for the one star is that the Kindle edition does not do justice to this book. First the price for the Kindle edition is astronomical. Second, there is no linked Table of Contents, nor structure to the book making it painful to use as a reference tool or classroom resource. This is a particular shame, given that the author has created an excellent structure to the contents in the book. The Kindle edition has ruined the experience of reading this book, buy the hardcopy.
For the most part Ayres gives us a magisterial survey and exposition of the Nicene era. His goal is to identify and commend what he terms a "pro-Nicene" theology. His second goal is to combat a problematic understanding of Trinitarian theology: Eastern personalism vs. Western monism, also known as the "De Regnon" Thesis. He begins his narrative as most do--with a discussion of Origen. Ayres helpfully notes that early Christian thinkers were reticent to use the term "homousios" since it implied a material division in God. Also, "hypostasis" was seen as connoting a reality; therefore, thinkers were reluctant to confess multiple realities in God. Ayres then continues with a long discussion of Athanasios. While he gives us much useful information and helpfully establishes the context, he really isn't breaking any new ground. Ayres' key sections deal with explicating his "pro-Nicene" theology, particularly as the Cappadocians relate to Augustine. He gives us very helpful analyses of the two Gregories and Hilary. Of his erudition and scholarship there can be no doubt. This will likely serve as a standard reference for doctoral students, and rightly so. I do not think his analyses are wrong, just incomplete. I agree with Ayres that simplistic readings of "Greek vs. West" are wrong. I just don't see it as really that prevalent, even among Orthodox scholars. They only people I've seen fret over this issue are Ayres' disciples. Even a radical Orthodox scholar like Joseph Farrell--who wrote a 1,200 page critique of forms of Western culture, never reduced scholarship to those categories. I honestly think Ayres is shadow-boxing dead Frenchmen. Ayres' protestations against dead Frenchmen notwithstanding, one must pursue this line of thought a bit further. De Regnon did not make up this "persons vs. essence" historiography. St Hilary of Poitiers was acutely aware of it. No one is claiming that the Evil Latins begin with the one essence while the Trinitarian Greeks begin with the Persons. Rather, one is making the argument that formulating theology within a specific philosophical framework reduces the persons to the one essence (shades of Aquinas!). St Hilary specifically identifies this problem in De Synodis 67-69. He said if you start with the one essence (homousion) as a template for theology, you will end up with modalism. While I can agree with his arguments on what constitutes a pro-Nicene theology, I don't see how this category is any more logically tight than de Regnon's. I suspect that Ayres commits the "Word = concept" fallacy in his chapter on divine simplicity. He appears to work under the assumption that the "pro-Nicene" guys used the term "simplicity" (aplosis) univocally, notably Augustine. I think one example will suffice. In de Trinitate Book VII (and numerous other places) Augustine identifies person and essence, along with identifying within God all of God's attributes. If all of the attributes are identifiable with the divine essence, and the divine essence admits of no distinctions, then all of the attributes are identifiable (synonymous) with each other. Interestingly, this is what Ayres' student Andrew Radde-Galwitz calls the "Identity Thesis." Fair enough; Augustine is entitled to it. In Letter 234 St Basil specifically identifies the Identity Thesis and rejects it (along similar lines as recent analytical philosophers did). Therefore, I don't see how Ayres can claim that Augustine and the Cappadocians taught the same thing on simplicity.ConclusionThis book is outstanding on so many levels. The student gets much information on key passages in Athanasios and the Cappadocians. The book occasionally borders on overkill and Ayres' constant raising and rebutting the "De Regnon" Thesis gets old very quickly. Since the book was written in 2003, some passages probably need to be cross-referenced with more recent
Fine selection of excellent quality and free cookbooks.
Nicaea and Its Legacy: An Approach to Fourth-Century Trinitarian Theology PDF
Nicaea and Its Legacy: An Approach to Fourth-Century Trinitarian Theology EPub
Nicaea and Its Legacy: An Approach to Fourth-Century Trinitarian Theology Doc
Nicaea and Its Legacy: An Approach to Fourth-Century Trinitarian Theology iBooks
Nicaea and Its Legacy: An Approach to Fourth-Century Trinitarian Theology rtf
Nicaea and Its Legacy: An Approach to Fourth-Century Trinitarian Theology Mobipocket
Nicaea and Its Legacy: An Approach to Fourth-Century Trinitarian Theology Kindle
Nicaea and Its Legacy: An Approach to Fourth-Century Trinitarian Theology PDF
Nicaea and Its Legacy: An Approach to Fourth-Century Trinitarian Theology PDF
Nicaea and Its Legacy: An Approach to Fourth-Century Trinitarian Theology PDF
Nicaea and Its Legacy: An Approach to Fourth-Century Trinitarian Theology PDF
Related posts
Share this post
0 komentar: